"Shaitan," starring Ajay Devgn and R. Madhavan, has garnered a mix of reactions from critics. Here's a consolidated review based on various critiques:
Plot and Premise: The film, directed by Vikas Bahl, is a horror thriller that revolves around a couple, played by Ajay Devgn and Jyothika, who encounter a mysterious stranger named Vanraaj, portrayed by R. Madhavan. The stranger turns out to be an occultist who possesses their daughter, leading to a desperate battle to save her
Critics' Opinions:
- The Hindu praised the film for its "poignant premise and powerful performances," highlighting Madhavan's portrayal of the antagonist as a standout. The review noted that the film manages to engage the audience with its emotional depth and creepy twists.
- India Today, however, criticized the film for a "weak script" that left many questions unanswered, particularly regarding the antagonist's motives. The review expressed disappointment in the second half of the film, which seemed to rely on gimmicks rather than solid storytelling.
- Firstpost described "Shaitan" as a "complete mess," criticizing its predictability and lack of believability. The review suggested that the film failed to deliver a compelling supernatural thriller³.
- The New Indian Express echoed similar sentiments, calling the film "torture porn" that was "relentlessly evil but just for the sake of it," lacking a method to its madness
- On a positive note, The Times of India commended the film for its sinister atmosphere and stellar performances, particularly lauding Madhavan's outstanding role as the malevolent figure⁵.
"Shaitan" seems to have divided critics, with some appreciating the performances and the eerie setup, while others found fault with the script and execution. The film appears to have moments that shine, thanks to the actors' efforts, but also suffers from a narrative that doesn't always hold up to scrutiny. It's a movie that might appeal to fans of the horror genre looking for a few scares and some strong acting, but it may not satisfy those seeking a well-rounded and thoroughly explained story.